Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s story “The Yellow Wallpaper”, is a
commentary on mental health in the late 1800s. You can connect the story to how
mental health was treated, how women in general were treated, and different
themes dealing with isolation or confinement. There are countless discussion
points one could make about this story. I want to take a closer look into the
actual wallpaper and what it symbolizes throughout the story.
Before
Gilman even brings us into the room with yellow wallpaper we get the sense that
there is something off in this house. The house is surprisingly available for
John and his wife to live in. The narrator explains that “there was some legal
trouble… anyhow, the place has been empty for years” (486). Even when the
narrator is describing the house in a positive way I got the sense that there
was more to the story.
“The Most
beautiful place! It is quite alone, standing well back from the road, quite
three miles from the village. It makes me think of English places that you read
about, for there are hedges and walls and gates that lock…” (486).
So it’s a beautiful
old house. But it’s secluded from everything around them. Even on the grounds
the landscaping and the architecture is closing you in and keeping you away
from the outside world. The hedges act as a barriers, the walls close you in,
things lock you out, or most likely, in. It gives the reader an uneasy feeling
and the narrator is left feeling uneasy about it.
“There is
something strange about the house – I can feel it.” (486).
As we move into the
house we are introduced to the room upstairs where John and the narrator will
be sleeping. The narrator implies that it used to be a nursery and that’s why
the windows have bars over them. That may be true, it may be some lie she tells
herself to better her situation. Regardless, the bars over the window add to
the isolation of the house and can contain her in her room easier. But what
stands out to the narrator is the wallpaper in the room.
“The paint
and paper look as if a boys’ school had used it. It is stripped off – the paper
– in great patches all around the head of my bed, about as far as I can reach,
and in a great place on the other side of the room low down. I never saw a
worse paper in my life.” (487).
She goes onto describe is as patterns that “[commit] every
artistic sin” (487), “smoldering unclean yellow” (487), and patterns that look
like “they suddenly commit suicide” (487). It is not a pleasant wallpaper. It
seems that the wallpaper is really distracting her from his sickness, whatever
it may be, and the fact that she is stuck in this secluded house in a room with
bars on the window. She begins to think that wallpaper is growing on her and
that she likes her room so much because of it. It starts to become an obsession
of hers. And soon it starts to mirror her own situation.
She starts
to see this woman in the wallpaper. The woman moves around in the wallpaper;
she is “stooping down and creeping about behind the pattern” (491). She starts
to think that the woman wants to get out from behind the paper. As the story
progresses the woman in the wallpaper becomes clearer and clearer to the
narrator. It sort of has an inverse relationship with the narrators mental
health. As she digresses the hallucinations progress. She starts to notice at
night that the patterns “becomes bars! The outside pattern… and the woman
behind it is as plain as could be.” (492). I feel that this reflects the
narrators actual situation. She is barred into her room. The outside of the
house could be like the outside pattern that keeps her trapped in this room. And
she’s the woman stuck in there wanting to get out. More and more the narrator
starts to draw parallels with the woman in the wallpaper. “By daylight she is
subdued, quiet…. It keeps me quiet by the hour.” (493). Both the wallpaper
woman and the narrator are active at night and quiet during the day. As the
story goes on it seems that the two merge to become one. By the end of the
story the two are indistinguishable. The narrator becomes her hallucination. It
makes me wonder if the whole time she has been this woman in the wallpaper.
Maybe she just didn’t realize what she was doing at night and she created this
other woman to explain everything. This just goes to explain how difficult
mental health problems can be to the individual. When reality is out of the question
what does someone have left? Should someone in this state of mind be left alone
in an old house at all? No one should feel like they are trapped behind anything
forced to “creep” around in the hopes of getting out one day. People shouldn’t
be forced to feel this way. There needs to be other ways to help people who are
not in the right state of mind.
I also got a very confined feeling from the house, bars on the windows, a gate on the door, in the middle of nowhere, all of these things really added to the sense of isolation or confinement of the character. I like your association with her being trapped. Towards the end of the story i kind of saw the room as being her mind, and she's trapped inside, and the wallpaper as the boarders of sanity. Even though i think the wallpaper was trying to warn or scare her away, she shreds it along with her sanity. I find it really disturbing to think about how many women went through a similar "treatment" throughout history, and forced to go through it alone.
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting to take that wide view of the strange, isolated house itself and then focus in ever so slowly....I wonder if anyone has made a claim that the house is her whole body, and that room and the wallpaper is her mind...
ReplyDeleteI think you chose really great quotations, especially the one where she's referring to how the wallpaper is all ripped up. This is one of my favorites from the story because it really makes you wonder if she was the one tearing it all along. It really makes you question her a narrator because she seems to not even know that she's already off her mental rocker. But most of all, it's just pretty creepy.
ReplyDeleteI too noticed the foreshadowing, but I think you did a good job of pointing out just how ominous and menacing the house really was. Interesting how you connected the house itself to a feeling of isolation and loneliness, the house sure was creepy! Also, good commentary at the end on how mental illness is treated and how difficult it can be to pinpoint exactly what is wrong. I agree that those with mental illnesses should not be forced inside a room or confined, we need to find other ways to help and treat them.
ReplyDelete